Mike’s Pizza Shoppe

Reviews

• Joe McAllister

  star star star star star 13 June 2026

  Just had a bacon and pepperoni pizza from Mikes and it was the best we ever had! Great job!

• Mandi Hoff

  star star star star star_border 6 June 2026

  There's nothing inherently wrong or necessarily amazing about Mike's: it's consistent and we've never had a terrible pie but it's not someplace we really get excited about and they don't really have specials like some other joints. The Sicilian pie is pretty good, the regular pie is ok. We usually order extra cheese and for us, what we receive doesn't seem to be extra-cheesy. The location is convenient but sometimes parking can be a serious hassle.

• Rina Overby

  star star star star star_border 2 June 2026

  Good pizza and quick serving. Super good crust and tasty. Lots of different topping options. We ordered the house pizza and it was loaded with toppings. They definitely aren't stingy with them. It was a good price for good pizza.

• Nathaniel Kuhn

  star star_border star_border star_border star_border 26 May 2026

  I decided to look around the West Chester area for potential caterers for my Rehearsal Dinner and came across Mike's Pizza. They're food is usually fairly decent aside from the occasional mess ups which I understand happen. I approached the manager/owner and requested a quote on a large tray of lasagna, a large tray of chicken Parmesan, 2 small trays of salad & garlic bread. He took my information and wanted to call me back the following day -- which I did not hear from him! I had to go back to the restaurant 2 days later and talk to him once more in order to get the price, which was $190. I was happy with this price and decided to overlook the lack of communication on their part, I even decided I wanted an additional large tray of Baked Ziti (which we didn't discuss a price before leaving but figured it'd be around $280-$300). Fast forward 2 weeks, I come in to pick up my order, the salads are great, the garlic bread is great but then I see all my main dishes are in SMALL trays which are about half the size of the large trays! I talk to the manager/owner and ask if I can get another small tray of Baked Ziti quick since this wouldn't have been enough to feed my party to which he agreed. I then asked about the price since I paid the original $190 for 3/4's of the food to which he charged me an additional $40 for the new tray of Baked Ziti! He then printed out the attached receipt telling me I should be happy with the price since he "gave" me a deal initially! I ended up paying the extra $40 because I really needed the extra food for my party. Long story short, the manager/owner expected me to overlook their huge mistake with my order & pay MORE to fix it just because he gave me a "deal" (which as far as I can tell was 100% made up just to get me out of their hair -- see the Custom Items & Prices in the attached receipt). These prices are not listed on their menu & I was not initially inquiring about a "deal", I was seeking their ACTUAL prices for what I requested which he stated would be $190 for all of the initial order (large tray of Lasagna & Chicken Parmesan with salads & bread). Attached is the "actual" catering prices he provided, I hope this will help future enquirers with their orders from Mike's Pizza! These prices are actually pretty steep for the area. - Small Salad tray: $19.99 (comes with dressings) - Garlic Bread: $1.00 per - Small Tray of Lasagna: $75.00 - Small Tray of Chicken Parmesan: $75.00 - Small Tray of Baked Ziti: $40.00 As far as the food goes, the Chicken Parmesan & Lasagna were pretty good but the Baked Ziti was really watery. The salads were great as well.

• Erika Saltzburg

  star star star star star 17 May 2026

  The staff is extremely friendly. You're greeted with a smile the second you walk in. They get super busy and still maintain accuracy and great quality food. They appreciate and respect your business and it shows. Highly recommend!!